Sunday, April 01, 2007

Aaila! Tendulkar!

Tendulkar should consider quitting - Ian Chappell

I don't agree with the conclusion of this article but some of the points being brought up are correct. First off, I don't believe Tendu is playing for the sake of statistics.
One of the biggest problems is that Tendu does not have a role in the team. Give him a role and ask him to perform in that role and I believe he will get it done. Anyway here is the article...
ps: Navjot Singh Sidhu is the biggest ass on all of cricket TV today. This guy never talks logically and only uses clichés that make no sense. He doesn’t give other people a chance to talk at all, cutting them with some dumb lines that only he thinks are smart. He is so irritating that given a choice I would pick to even watch Mandira Bedi over him.

(via CricInfo)
Ian Chappell

In the fallout from India's early demise at the World Cup one of the major decisions will concern the future of Sachin Tendulkar.
Before anybody else makes a decision on what will happen to Tendulkar the player himself has to have a good long look in the mirror and decide what he's trying to achieve in the game. At the moment he looks like a player trying to eke out a career; build on a glittering array of statistics. If he really is playing for that reason and not to help win as many matches as he can for India then he is wasting his time and should retire immediately.
When you think that for a decade Brian Lara and Tendulkar went head to head in a wonderful battle of stroke play to establish who was the best batsman in the world, they are now worlds apart in effectiveness.
Lara's quick-footed tip toe through a terrific innings against a good Australian bowling attack when the rest of the West Indies top order succumbed easily was in direct contrast to Tendulkar's stumbling effort in the crucial Sri Lanka match. The amazing thing about Lara's brilliant career is the fact that he hasn't changed his style at all over seventeen years. This is a credit to his technique and mental strength, as the aging process generally makes a player more progressively conservative.
Tendulkar hasn't worn as well; his last three or four years have been a shadow of his former self. His double century at the SCG in January 2004 was a classic case of a great player really struggling. He came to the crease out of form and despite amassing all those runs and batting for in excess of ten hours he was no closer to recapturing his best touch than he was when he started out. It was a tribute to his determination but it was a sad sight to see; there are enough average players around that you don't won't to see a class one reduced to that level.
Tendulkar hasn't been as lucky as Lara; the Indian batsman has suffered a lot of injuries in this period where his play has deteriorated and there is nothing that melts your mental approach quicker than physical handicaps. Lara has been relatively free from injury and he certainly doesn't have the weight of numbers riding on his shoulders that Tendulkar does.
However, the population of the Caribbean might be small but they are extremely demanding. Despite all the fuss and the odd controversy that has surrounded Lara's career he has remained himself; this is my game and that is how I play. For whatever reason Tendulkar hasn't been able to maintain his extremely high standards for the last few years and unless he can find a way to recapture this mental approach he's not doing his team or himself any favours.
If Tendulkar had found an honest mirror three years ago and asked the question; "Mirror, mirror on the wall who is the best batsman of all?" It would've answered; "Brian Charles Lara." If he asked that same mirror right now; "Mirror, mirror on the wall should I retire?" The answer would be; "Yes."

12 comments:

sid said...

I don't know man..unless he changes his approach, he should make way for a younger player.

His batting has completely lost it's audacity. He has become an overtly defensive player - take for example his three innings in the third test respectively against Pakistan, England and SA. He let himself be dominated by rookie spinners in all three games. He was the biggest reason why India lost all three tests. I am not picking on him. No one player should be blamed for defeats like these. But the problem is that the rest of the team looks up to him, and when he goes into his shell, the rest of the team follows.

Kaif should be made the captain, and Raina should be brought back into the team. No team with Ganguly and Munaf on the field can hope to win much. Cricket is a different game now, and the publix need to realize that just because Ganguly has scored some runs in his comeback doesn't make it a successful one. He fails in every other dept, and so does Tendulkar. Laxman is at least good in the slips. India is just not being able to keep up with the changing game...

Bharat said...

He CAN change his approach but only if the coach puts him in a definite role and asks him to stick there. In batting everyone has a role Ganguly (opener), Dravid (one down), Yuvraj and Dhoni except this guy. I think send him back as an opener but let him go to English county where the pitches are fast and the ball swings and then I feel he'll be back to his usual stuff...I believe he is a little lost today...

I don't believe Tendulkar fails in the fielding department...he is a good outfielder who anticipates and chases every ball with heart...

But the way the game is played has changed. One more player I feel we should trust more and send to English county for a stint is Pathan. I really feel the team management and the media have played havoc with him...we need him back...

sid said...

Yes, Pathan is the biggest loss. He was a wicket taker. We have none right now.

Tendulkar is good in the outfield, but that's about it. He just seems to have lost it mentally at the crease. I don't know man..I was a huge fan, and would still like him to be his old self. But I don't know whether he can.

The team is a mess. It's best to start from scratch. Bring in some more match winners...

Bharat said...

Why Kaif? Mental toughness? Fielding?
But his form with the bat became really bad. I don't know how he is doing in the domestic cricket now...

sid said...

Doesn't matter. He saves 20 runs on the field. He is not a super talented batsman, but can run like a mutha, and is excellent for the 20-40 over period. Plus the guy is down to earth, and will fight.

There is no way Ganguly should be playing in the one day team, period. Unfortunately, I feel that Chappell will be the only casualty.

Bharat said...

Oh! Based on yesterday's revelations of the cricket 'mafia' and the behaviour of some players, Chappell will definitely be a casualty and probably the only one...Now they will get an Indian coach who can handle the politics and he will end up keeping Indian cricket at exactly where it is today while the rest of the world beat us left and right...

sid said...

We are goners. GC is excellent technically, but seems like he is not a good people's manager. But...why the f*** do these grown ups playing for their country need mollycoddling? It sucks. They are saying GC doesn't understand our culture, and players. They should, however, be saying that the culture should be forced to change. Do we want to beat Aus and SA or not?? Mohinder Amarnath for coach! Give me a break...

Bharat said...

Hooray! We are screwed!!!
When Ganguly came back this is exactly what I was worried about and that guy has turned out to be a slick snake...

Imagine how bad we were if B'desh could beat us easily by 5 wickets is now getting trashed by Australia by 10 wickets and NZ by 9 wickets...

sid said...

Well...GC is gone. The rest will still be around. I am extremely disappointed with Tendu's crying game. He has become a loser man. Doesn't perform, just wants to survive on his past laurels. In that series against WI, he took a single off the last ball of the 50th over to complete his century, instead of trying to slog it for more runs. If it was any other player of any other country, he would have been castrated in the media for a selfish action like that.

A bunch of losers...

Bharat said...

Thw whole world is probably laughing at us...crappy stuff from everyone...

sid said...

I hope Tendu gets dropped along with Gang. Yuvraj should be dropped too because of his attitude, but he has too much talent to be ignored. Every match, we should have Kaif, Raina and Yuvraj manning the point and Cover region. The team should be built around that. I actually think we should persist with Sehwag. Sehwag and Utthappa can open. Tendu should be given 15 more games to prove he still has it, but he should be dropped for a series first. Sreesanth and Ramesh Powar should be brought in too. Bhajji can go suck on something. Dravid should lead the team for the next 2-3 years. He is honorable, and has become a fighter.

Bharat said...

But it doesn't look like any of the players will be dropped. The blame is being passed around and shared...generally a very soft stance has been taken.

I agree with Jadeja that everyone is focusing on the B'desh tour which is wrong. We'll go to B'desh and win with huge margins there and come back, then everyone will think we are back in form and all the troubles have been left behind and we'll just keep going round and round in circles...